Too early?
Ok. So we all know that baseball isn't an exact science. If it was, then well, it doesn't really bear thinking about. Now, I love prospects. I love talking about them. Evaluating them. Reading scouting reports on them. Predicting what might happen to them in the upcoming season and just generally basking in their buzz. But what I can't stand is when a young prospect gets burned because he's abused or brought up to early and has his confidence destroyed, never fulfulling half of what was promised.
For me then, as a Tigers fan, you can understand that the alarm bells might be sounding off when I hear Jim Leyland express that he might take 'a young guy' if someone emerges. In other words, Ryan Perry and Rick Porcello. And yes, I can accept that this gamble does work on occasion. Look at Joel Zumaya and Justin Verlander. They both excelled in 2006. But then I just take one glance at Andrew Miller and a big lump appears in my throat. Miller, for all that attention, was pretty much drilled into the ground when the Tigers rushed him to the big leagues in both 2006 and 2007. And now look at him. He couldn't really quite find his groove in Florida last year. So who knows. He's still a tremendous young arm, and I'm not going to dismiss him, but for his development, it would have served him better in my opinion to have spent all of 2007 in the minors.
And I don't want the same thing to happen to Perry or Porcello. Both guys have tremendous arms. Potential galore. But lets look at the facts. Perry's pitched 13 2/3 innings in the minors and hasn't pitched above class A Lakeland. Is he ready to face major league hitters in clutch situations? So what, he has a triple digit fastball, but does that make him ready? Not in my opinion. Porcello was downright dominant last season at Lakeland, with a 2.66 ERA in 125 innings, and he stayed at Lakeland all year. Again, he hasn't pitched above A ball. These guys are the future. There's a reason why you go out and you get non-roster invitees or you sign guys like Scott Williamson and Juan Rincon to minor league deals.
These guys are the future of this ballclub. I don't want to see them ruined by calling them up too early. September's a different story. The minor league season ends at the end of August. They would have had the whole year. Let them force your hand from down on the farm in the late summer, not in spring.
Of course, this begs the fundamental question. When really is too early? Some guys it seems, need several years before they're ready. Some need a couple of months. But there's no substitute for learning down on the farm. The speed of the game is slower. Your mistakes are no where near as magnified. There's not the intesity of the media or the fans following your every move. It's the perfect spring board. But some guys just take it all in stride and can handle being thrown in at the deep end. Only time will tell what Tigers management will do with Perry and Porcello. But my opinion is its definitely too early. Their times will come. Just wait a year, and I'll sit back and relax and let the excitment and buzz grow as they light up the minors in 2009.
For me then, as a Tigers fan, you can understand that the alarm bells might be sounding off when I hear Jim Leyland express that he might take 'a young guy' if someone emerges. In other words, Ryan Perry and Rick Porcello. And yes, I can accept that this gamble does work on occasion. Look at Joel Zumaya and Justin Verlander. They both excelled in 2006. But then I just take one glance at Andrew Miller and a big lump appears in my throat. Miller, for all that attention, was pretty much drilled into the ground when the Tigers rushed him to the big leagues in both 2006 and 2007. And now look at him. He couldn't really quite find his groove in Florida last year. So who knows. He's still a tremendous young arm, and I'm not going to dismiss him, but for his development, it would have served him better in my opinion to have spent all of 2007 in the minors.
And I don't want the same thing to happen to Perry or Porcello. Both guys have tremendous arms. Potential galore. But lets look at the facts. Perry's pitched 13 2/3 innings in the minors and hasn't pitched above class A Lakeland. Is he ready to face major league hitters in clutch situations? So what, he has a triple digit fastball, but does that make him ready? Not in my opinion. Porcello was downright dominant last season at Lakeland, with a 2.66 ERA in 125 innings, and he stayed at Lakeland all year. Again, he hasn't pitched above A ball. These guys are the future. There's a reason why you go out and you get non-roster invitees or you sign guys like Scott Williamson and Juan Rincon to minor league deals.
These guys are the future of this ballclub. I don't want to see them ruined by calling them up too early. September's a different story. The minor league season ends at the end of August. They would have had the whole year. Let them force your hand from down on the farm in the late summer, not in spring.
Of course, this begs the fundamental question. When really is too early? Some guys it seems, need several years before they're ready. Some need a couple of months. But there's no substitute for learning down on the farm. The speed of the game is slower. Your mistakes are no where near as magnified. There's not the intesity of the media or the fans following your every move. It's the perfect spring board. But some guys just take it all in stride and can handle being thrown in at the deep end. Only time will tell what Tigers management will do with Perry and Porcello. But my opinion is its definitely too early. Their times will come. Just wait a year, and I'll sit back and relax and let the excitment and buzz grow as they light up the minors in 2009.
